Google Photos is the default photo backup for billions of Android phones, and plenty of iPhones too. It's free to start, it works in the background, and its search is excellent. So why would anyone copy their photos to a USB drive instead?
Because Google Photos and a drive you own answer different questions. One keeps your photos reachable from anywhere. The other keeps a copy that doesn't depend on an account, a subscription or an internet connection. This comparison covers where each one wins, and why many people end up using both.
Quick answer: Google Photos stores your photos on Google's servers, with 15 GB free shared with Gmail and Drive, and paid plans from $1.99 a month. VaultDrive copies original-quality photos to a USB drive you own, with no account, no internet and a one-time $19.99 Pro price. Google Photos is better for search and sharing; a drive is better as an independent backup. Most people should use both.
How do Google Photos and VaultDrive compare?
| Google Photos | VaultDrive | |
|---|---|---|
| Where your photos live | Google's servers | A USB drive or SSD you own |
| Price | 15 GB free, then from $1.99 a month | Free up to 200 files or 2 GB per backup; Pro $19.99 once |
| Account | Google Account required | None |
| Internet | Needed to back up and to view | Not needed |
| Quality | Original, or reduced with Storage saver | Original, byte for byte |
| Space | Your plan, shared with Gmail and Drive | As big as your drive |
| Backs up | Photos and videos | Photos, videos, and files and folders you pick |
| Runs | Automatically in the background | When you plug in the drive, with reminders |
| Search and sharing | Excellent | Not its job |
Google prices are US prices from Google One, checked November 19, 2026.
What does Google Photos cost?
Every Google Account comes with up to 15 GB of free storage, and that space is shared between Gmail, Google Drive and Google Photos (Google). For most people with a few years of photos, 15 GB runs out.
After that, it's a subscription. In the US, Google One lists Basic with 100 GB at $1.99 a month, Google AI Plus with 2 TB at $9.99 a month, and Google AI Pro with 5 TB at $19.99 a month (Google One). The bill continues for as long as you want your photos stored there.
VaultDrive is free to try, and Pro is a one-time $19.99 purchase. You also buy a drive, once, sized for your library. There's no monthly bill.
Does Google Photos keep the original quality?
It can. Google Photos has two backup quality settings. Original quality stores photos and videos at the resolution you took them. Storage saver resizes photos larger than 16 MP down to 16 MP and videos above 1080p down to 1080p (Google).
Storage saver is tempting when you're running out of space, but those smaller copies are what you'd get back. If your phone shoots 50 MP photos or 4K video, that's a real loss.
VaultDrive always copies the original file, byte for byte. HEIC, RAW, 4K and high-resolution videos are copied as they are, never re-encoded, with the capture date and location inside each file kept intact. Every file is checked after it's copied.
Who can see your photos?
With Google Photos, your photos are uploaded to Google and stored in your Google Account. Google offers controls over how your data is used, and you should read its privacy settings to decide what you're comfortable with.
With VaultDrive, photos travel over the cable to your drive. They're never uploaded to a cloud, and never sent to our servers. There's no account, no email, no login. App Lock with your fingerprint, face or screen lock keeps the app itself private.
The trade-off: a drive is a physical object. Keep it somewhere safe, and keep a second copy somewhere else if the photos are irreplaceable.
What happens when something goes wrong?
This is where the two differ most.
| Situation | Google Photos | Your own drive |
|---|---|---|
| You delete a photo by mistake | Removed from Google Photos and synced devices; stays in Trash for 30 days (Google) | The drive copy is untouched |
| You run out of storage | New backups stop; after 2 years out of storage, photos might be deleted (Google) | Buy a bigger drive or a second one |
| You stop paying | You drop back to 15 GB shared space | Nothing changes |
| You lose access to your account | Your library is out of reach until you recover it | No account involved |
| You lose your phone | Photos are safe in your account | Photos are safe up to your last backup |
| Your house floods | Photos are safe in the cloud | The drive may be lost too, unless a copy is elsewhere |
Neither column wins every row. That's the point: they fail in different ways, so together they cover each other. Our guide to the 3-2-1 backup rule explains why two different kinds of copy beat one.
Can you get your photos back out of Google Photos?
Yes, through Google Takeout, but it's not tidy. Takeout delivers your library as zip archives, splitting large libraries across several files of up to 50 GB. Each photo comes with a separate JSON file holding details like the date, location and description, and if those aren't merged back, some apps show the wrong date or no location (Pixel Union).
A drive copy made from your phone doesn't have that problem. The details stay inside each photo, and the files are already organised in folders by date or by album.
What does Google Photos do better?
To be fair, Google Photos does things a drive can't:
- Search. Type "beach 2019" or a friend's name and find photos in seconds.
- Access anywhere. Any phone, tablet or browser, without carrying anything.
- Sharing. Shared albums and links that work for anyone.
- Automatic backup. New photos upload in the background without you doing anything.
If you rely on those, keep using it.
What does VaultDrive do better?
- One payment. $19.99 once for Pro, no subscription.
- No account. Nothing to sign in to, recover or get locked out of.
- Works offline. On a plane, abroad or with no signal.
- Originals, always. No compressed version, ever.
- As much space as your drive. No plan to upgrade.
- More than photos on Android. Back up the files and folders you pick, too.
- One drive for the family. Each phone gets its own folder.
So which one should you use?
For most people: both. Let Google Photos handle everyday access, search and sharing. Keep a VaultDrive copy on a drive at home as the copy that doesn't depend on Google, a subscription or the internet.
If you're paying Google only because you've run out of space, a drive can take your older photos and videos, and you can decide what stays in the cloud.
On Android, you'll need a USB-C flash drive or SSD, or an OTG adapter for a USB-A drive. Our guide to backing up Android photos to a USB drive walks through it. VaultDrive also works on iPhone.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Google Photos free?
Up to 15 GB, shared with Gmail and Google Drive. After that you need a Google One plan.
Does Google Photos compress my photos?
Only if you choose Storage saver, which resizes photos over 16 MP and videos over 1080p. Original quality keeps them as taken but uses more storage.
Can I use VaultDrive and Google Photos together?
Yes. They don't interfere. VaultDrive copies the photos on your phone to your drive, whether or not they're also in Google Photos.
Does VaultDrive upload anything?
No. Your photos go over the cable to your drive. VaultDrive doesn't need an internet connection or an account.
What happens to Google Photos if I stop paying?
You drop back to 15 GB. If you're over that, new photos stop backing up, and after 2 years out of storage Google says your photos might be deleted.
Is Google Photos a backup?
It backs up your photos to your Google Account. But deleting a photo in Google Photos also removes it from your synced devices, and it's gone for good after 30 days in Trash. Keep a separate copy that doesn't depend on the account.
The short version
Google Photos is great for finding and sharing photos from anywhere. It costs a monthly fee once you pass 15 GB, needs an account and the internet, and depends on keeping both. VaultDrive keeps an original-quality copy on a drive you own, for a one-time price, with no account at all. Use Google for convenience and a drive for independence.
Related guides: USB Backup vs Cloud Backup · Backup vs. Sync · How to Back Up Android Photos to a USB Drive
About VaultDrive: VaultDrive is an iPhone and Android app by Coticsy that backs up photos, videos and files straight to a USB drive or SSD, with no computer, no cloud and no account. Free to try; Pro is $19.99 once.
About the author: Himaja B is a co-founder of Coticsy, the studio that makes VaultDrive.